| Opinions of Works by James Stevens Curl
On
The Victorian Celebration
of Death
‘...The
Victorian Celebration of
Death...is a serious study of a neglected element of town
planning, traced through the nineteenth century ... A ... delightfully
produced book’ Helen Woolmer in Town
and County Planning (March 1973)
‘The
post-Victorian celebration of death is resurrected ... by ...
Mr Curl, whose perceptive views on the whys and wherefores of
the 19th century necropolis are of considerable importance’ Gerard
Turner in The Oxford Times
(24 March 1972)
‘Mr
Curl is clearly a dedicated and erudite cemeterian’ J. W. Burrow
in The Times (13 April
1972)
‘Cemeteries
have a history that is worth writing...Mr Curl has been the first
to put it into a readable, well-informed, and moderately priced
book’ Howard Colvin in The
Oxford Mail (16
March 1972)
‘We
should be grateful to Mr Curl for this excellent book’ K. Lichtenstein
in the R.I.B.A. Journal
(June 1972)
‘The
Victorian Celebration of Death is a beautifully decorated
volume ... Mr Curl’s book combines wit with compassion – the art,
incidentally, of the great humorists. His research into the periphery
of the outward manifestation of funeralia is minute and fascinating.
He proceeds from Father Abraham to cremation with scarcely a jolt
and his reportage of the cemeteries ... makes his elegant book
an acceptable companion to the non-eternal bedside’ Caryl Brahms
in The Guardian (3
April 1972)
‘The
Victorian Celebration of Death... is ... a most entertaining
and enterprising book - a book finely produced, moreover, with
a mass of apt and enlightening illustrations...In these days of
chronic over-production one cannot often say that a book fills
a genuine gap, but in this case it is true. Mr Curl ... has much
to say of interest, and has rescued so much absorbing information
from oblivion... that I can only recommend you to acquire his
book; it is entirely delightful’ Martin Fagg in The
Church Times (30 March 1972)
‘The
Victorian Celebration of Death... is ... lucid and entertaining.
Curl has done a great deal of research on the formation of the
private companies that established rural necropoleis...’ Cedric
Flower in The Bulletin
(22
July 1972)
‘The
pleasures of the cemetery ... here a thrilling note is struck.
out comes pouring from the great black cornucopia of Victorian
agony the horrific paraphernalia of pompes
funèbres, presented in The
Victorian Celebration of Death as well ordered as any sumptuous
funeral. This well-researched book...describes some associated
delights ... Mr Curl’s taste for the eerie flows beneath a level
literary style. His literary personality is modest and unobtrusive,
as befits his subject’ Alfred Brew in the
Times Educational Supplement (31
March 1972)
<<top
On Victorian
Architecture
‘Victorian
Architecture...is an agreeably written, well-researched, and
off-beat illustrated account of the ingenious and gargantuan ...
works of architectural moralists and engineering geniuses. Mr
Curl deals lovingly with esoteric details as well as with the
larger-than-life men and their vast schemes’ The
Sunday Times (2
December 1973)
‘Mr James
Stevens Curl has made a notable addition to the growing number
of books on Victorian Architecture. He writes well – his book
is intensely readable ... this is a very good book to have on
one’s shelf’ Robert Furneaux Jordan
in The Architects' Journal
(5 December
1973)
‘Mr
Curl pursues his robustly-argued case closely, passionately, and
with a loving scope...’ Michael McNay in The
Guardian (20
December 1973)
<<top
On
The Erosion of Oxford
‘...
books like this one are necessary to make us see through the dogmas
to the physical reality of what is happening today’ Gavin Stamp
in The Architectural Review
(June 1978)
<<top
On
English
Architecture: An Illustrated Glossary
‘Mr
Curl’s Glossary is refreshingly free from tiresome wordiness,
and the value of his succinct entries is enhanced by some 300
exceptionally clear illustrations ... Entries are short, pithy,
and always lucid. Mr Curl has mastered the difficult art of conveying
in a relatively small space all that it is absolutely necessary
to say.
This
work is far more than an illustrated assembly of technical terms:
apart from its considerable value as a reliable reference book,
it more than repays the attention of the casual browser, for so
many pages reveal new aspects of familiar examples, drawn from
our immense treasury of ancient buildings, and so many terms stimulate
fresh thoughts about our architectural past and our often peculiar
architectural present.
For
students, for teachers, and for all those who enjoy a vital interest
in architectural history and development, this book should provide
a stimulating experience...’ John Gloag in The
Journal of the Royal Society of Arts (September 1977)
‘An
essential book ... The most readable, visually attractive, and
concise of dictionaries ... It explains clearly... the finer aspects
... of architecture ...’ The
Architects' Journal (27
July 1977)
‘At
a time when professionals are perhaps a good deal less literate
in the language of building than they should be, it is good that
an authoritative glossary should have been produced in an easy-going
format. The illustrations are useful, mercifully unfamiliar, and
may help to make ignorant mistakes less likely. The author takes
the reader from Abaciscus ... to Yetts and Zotheca. This book
is a desirable possession for those intent on intellectual one-upmanship
and essential knowledge for all involved in conservation. Highly
recommended’ A. A. Wood in The
Journal of the Royal Town Planning Institute (September 1977)
<<top
On
Moneymore and Draperstown.
The Architecture and Planning of the Ulster
Estates of the Drapers’ Company
and The History, Architecture,
and Planning of the Estates of the Fishmongers’ Company in Ulster
‘In
the two Companies selected by Curl for study the developments
resulted in some works of architectural distinction of the neoclassical
type, especially in the work of W. J. Booth and Jesse Gibson at
Moneymore and Draperstown... and in that of Richard Suter at Ballykelly
... These monographs are so informative that they prompt the hope
that the whole story of the participation of London Companies
in the development of urban settlements in Ulster will be told...’
Arnold
Whittick in the Journal
of the Royal Society of Arts (October 1982)
<<top
On
A Celebration of Death
‘A
richly illustrated book ... Apart from its intrinsic interest,
Mr Curl’s Celebration reveals
an important historical point, the role of funerary architecture
in the development of architectural style...Mr Curl has paid due
regard to the tomb. I salute his study and recommend it for a
fresh look at immortality’ Patrick Nuttgens in The
Times (11.2.80)
‘A
source of wonder and delight...The book’s publication should itself
be celebrated, for its virtues are many and important’ Christopher
Ricks in The Sunday Times
(10.2.80)
‘James
Stevens Curl has established his credentials in this field ...
Mr Curl brings to his subject the zest which it demands. He is
more than half in love with his subject, and the excellence of
his illustrations fitly complements his text ... a prodigious
quantity of information is here assembled, as never before in
English’ Maurice Craig in
The Times Literary Supplement (29.2.80)
‘An
admirable culmination of research over several years...a fascinating
study’ Derek Linstrum in The
Yorkshire Post (18.1.80)
‘...the
book is timely and important ... Mr Curl has tackled a neglected
and largely uncharted subject, and he has drawn attention to much
splendid...architecture...I admire the book...’ Gavin Stamp in
The Spectator (22.3.80)
‘Funerary
architecture is not well documented. James Stevens Curl is, in
fact, one of the few writers to have made a speciality out of
his interest in this subject...The book’s 400 or so pages are
packed with fascinating information’ Stone
Industries (March 1980)
‘A
most astonishing work on funerary architecture ... of a positively
noble scope and sweep and scale’ John O’Callaghan in The
Oxford Times (15.2.80)
‘This
is a large and beautifully illustrated book...Mr Curl’s taste
is very catholic indeed...his text is a useful and interesting
presentation of very valuable material. He is excellent on Père-Lachaise,
and writes with warmth and perception about all the grander aspects
of his subject’ Philip Toynbee in The
Observer (24.2.80)
‘...a remarkably comprehensive survey of the subject’
Gillian Darley in The Financial
Times (8.3.80)
‘Mr
Curl comes into his own in ferreting out the unknown and the unexpected
... his book is a source of constant, never morbid, fascination’
The Economist (29.3.80)
‘...a
remarkable book by James Stevens Curl ... a study of funerary
architecture in the Western European tradition, sparingly entitled
A Celebration of Death.
I reviewed it at some length in The Times, and anyone who reads that
paper will know the high opinion I formed of the book’ Patrick
Nuttgens in The Times Higher
Education Supplement (21.8.81)
‘...
a unique work with a striking thesis ... by a distinguished Irish
architect, an honored scholar of his art and urban history’ Edmund
Fuller in The Wall Street
Journal
‘James
Stevens Curl’s A Celebration
of Death is a perfect complement to Ariès’ study and affords
an encyclopaedic view of buildings, monuments, and settings of
funerary architecture ... Pictorially well conceived, descriptively
rich in anecdotes and information, and culturally meaningful,
Curl’s book synthesises art and ideology’ Siegfried Mandel in
the San Diego Magazine
(May 1981)
‘
... extremely well researched and presented mixture of socio-history
and architectural history ... almost always ... fascinating and
readable...We are delighted to be able to recommend this work
most highly...’ Antiques
& The Arts Weekly (28.11.80)
‘Scribner’s
has long been regarded as a class publishing house, and nowhere
in recent memory does its professionalism come more quickly to
the fore than in James Stevens Curl’s A
Celebration of Death. Amply illustrated... the book gives
new insight into some of the Western world’s most stunning monuments
to the dead. Accompanying the
illustrations is Mr Curl’s text, which is a study in clarity,
historical acumen, and how a writer can combine elegant prose
with utter clarity without creating a style that is either overblown
or banal. A good book... it is ... interesting, highly informative,
and craftsmanlike in all respects’ American
Director New York (October 1980)
‘In
1972 Mr. Curl published The
Victorian Celebration of Death, an account of the beginnings
of the Victorian cemetery movement ... At that time the subject
had barely been examined, certainly never in such depth...The
Victorian Celebration provided the initial spark for many
of those now involved in this field; and it may fairly be said
that with that book Mr. Curl created cemetery studies as a scholarly
discipline. ‘Now he has brought out a sequel, which greatly expands
the range of what must now be called funerary studies. Historians
of landscape will be grateful for such a mass of information gathered
into one compass ... Mr. Curl has painted an enthralling picture
... I cannot leave the subject without commenting on a Celebration
as a physical object. it is a beautiful piece of bookmaking ...
Potential publishers of books on garden history ought to examine
this volume as an exemplary specimen’ Brent Elliott in Garden
History viii/3
(Winter 1980)
A
Celebration of Death...
‘the monumental work now before us cannot but be welcomed... the
immense amount of research that has gone into the present publication
is clear ... In all the rich variety of illustration and scholarly
comment which is placed before us one message comes over as clear
as the last trump - a monument is intended to be a lasting memorial
... This ... book... is an important and timely publication which
deserves to play a significant part in ensuring a proper appreciation
of, and greater respect for, our neighbours’ landmarks’ C. F.
Stell in The Antiquaries
Journal lxi Pt.1
(1981)
‘It’s
not exactly graves and graveyards, and in a sense it is festive
in that it’s about celebration. It is a celebration of lives that
are over and finished. Much of the world’s greatest architecture
has been about death; much of the world’s greatest music has been
about death. Think of the Taj Mahal, think of the Verdi Requiem,
think of Gray’s Elegy,
think of things like the Lament of
Art O’Leary, and we realise how death has given rise to
a great deal of fine art. This book is not so much about graveyards
as about monuments and tombs, above all, of course, mausolea.
The author covers the whole of Europe
and a little of the near east, as well as places outside Europe.
He says in his preface that his whole appetite for the subject
was whetted by a childhood spent in the melancholy landscape of
Ireland:
and Ireland
is rich in funerary architecture of one sort or another. The author
has covered his subject superbly well, and 1 think the whole production
is a very fine illustrated book. The pictures are of a very high
quality, and the author has done his homework thoroughly and professionally’
Maurice Craig on his Book Programme (6 January
1982) Radio Telefís Éireann
<<top
On
The History, Architecture,
and Planning of the Estates of
the Fishmongers’ Company in Ulster
‘The
bibliography testifies to the author’s depth and breadth of reading...
this book is valuable in introducing the subject of the London
City Companies’ involvement in Ireland or, for those who have
read the author’s work on the Drapers’ Company in Ulster, extending
knowledge of it. No praise can be too great for the U.A.H.S. which
has continued to produce admirable... monographs ...’ Lesley Lewis
in The Antiquaries Journal
lxii Pt.II (1982)
‘…an
able little book admirably condensing Ulster history yet retaining
sufficient detail to provide a readable and absorbing text...’
Alistair Rowan in Newsletter
28 of the Society
of Architectural Historians of Great Britain
(Summer 1983)
‘Dr.
James Stevens Curl’s monograph... should be essential reading
for anyone wishing to comprehend Northern
Ireland
today... He discusses the “survey and analysis” stages, when the
Government saw the plantation as a means of transforming “the
most rude and unreformed part of Ireland and the seat and nest
of the last great rebellion” into a law- abiding land and a source
of revenue, while also relieving what was considered over-population
in London. He reveals lucidly the provision of the Plan itself,
both physical and financial... Dr. Curl shows amply the role of
the Company’s servants and surveyors, and includes many original
drawings with the wealth of photographs which he has taken for
the study. This... publication disseminates knowledge, interprets
our heritage, and shows where and how illiterate alterations are
damaging that heritage ... The book is extremely good value...
It is a positive antidote to the all too frequent negative or
carping criticism which emanates from some civic societies’ Denis
McCoy in the Journal of
the Royal Town Planning Institute (September/October 1983)
<<top
On
The Egyptian Revival. An
Introductory Study of a Recurring Theme in the History of Taste
‘
... despite the author’s modest claim in the subtitle that this
is “an introductory study of a recurring theme in the history
of taste”. it is unlikely that a more comprehensive account of
the Egyptian influence on Western art and architecture will be
published this century.The
Egyptian Revival is a monumental work. Dr. Curl started researching
for the book over twenty years ago, and his painstaking scholarship
is proven by the immense scope of the volume.
Over 200 outstanding illustrations, the majority never before
published, enhance the presentation of this remarkable book which
will delight the interested layman and absorb the academic’ The Hampshire Chronicle (30
July 1982 )
‘The
story of Dr. Curl’s research – if so prosaic a word can be used
for what is more truly an adventure as thrilling as the myth of
Crete – is told in his latest book, The
Egyptian Revival.What makes this book a tour-de-force is the
breadth of knowledge and interest it reveals. Dr. Curl is an historian
of architecture by profession, but he is in truth a polymath,
whose interests cover European literature, music, and painting.
For the scholar and student, the book is equipped with meticulous
notes and a 20-page bibliography, as well as an efficient index.
But the erudition is lightly worn. The general reader will find
nothing daunting in the clearly-written text, enlivened by a wealth
of quotations, and by the author’s huge zest for his subject’
Helen Turner in The Oxford
Times (6 August 1982)
‘Dr.
Curl is eminently qualified to survey this broad sweep... his
long interest over some twenty years in the Egyptian Revival has
brought a vast amount of material together. As is to be expected,
there is an emphasis on architecture and especially funeral monuments
... (Curl’s previous book A
Celebration of Death... exhibits his specific interest and
rapport in this field). Dr. Curl, in his exceedingly detailed
survey that belies its sub-title ... gives us plenty to think
about in a very dense text replete with footnotes and extensive
bibliography. The illustrations are well presented and reproduced
and intriguingly stimulating... it cannot be said that Dr. Curl’s
treatment is anything but thorough. Others have taken aspects
of the Egyptian Revival in its various phases; here it can all
be seen in a rather splendid assemblage’ Peter A. Clayton in The
Journal of the Royal Society of Arts cxxxi/5324
(July 1983)
‘As
an architectural historian Dr. Curl is particularly strong on
tracking down Egyptian motifs in Renaissance art and architecture.
(There are) ... many good and fascinating things in his book...’
Christopher Booker in The
Sunday Telegraph (29
August 1982)
‘As
James Stevens Curl has brilliantly demonstrated in The Egyptian
Revival ... the idea of Egyptian culture has pervaded European
civilisation in varying degrees since Roman times ... Dr. Curl’s
marvellously informative book (is) handsomely illustrated...’
Derek Linstrum in The Yorkshire
Post
(6
September 1982)
‘The
definitive masterwork on the Egyptian Revival... This is a notable
publication on several counts. Prodigious research over many years
underpins no dry-as-dust monograph but a vivid and smooth narration,
as absorbing and readable as a first-rate biography. This lively
text is augmented by remarkable illustrative material of an unusual
historical, geographical and aesthetic range... This is, in every
department, a definitive work: generations of students will be
indebted to Dr. Curl’s rare dedication, passion, and precision’
House and Garden (October
1982) 154
‘The
Egyptian Revival ... is a phrase... not yet as familiar as ‘Gothic
Revival’ or ‘Greek Revival’ - but it may now be regarded as well
and truly coined. James Stevens Curl has made an impressive compilation
of European Borrowings from Egypt,
ranging from obelisks in imperial Rome to the Carlton Cinema in
Islington. He is at his best on funerary monuments ... and he
devotes a valuable section to the tradition of ‘Egyptian’ sets
for The Magic Flute.
(The book) covers ... much ground... Dr. Stevens Curl has opened
up an extensive and fertile
territory in which explorers of themes and motifs will
be occupied for many years’ Patrick Conner in Country
Life (23 September 1982)
‘Curl’s
wide geographic and chronological spectrum was necessary... (he)
... has come up with a surprisingly large trawl of Egyptiana.
The book is a grand conspectus of two millennia’s worth of the
continuing Egyptian decorative tradition... (it) is practically
all hard evidence’ Sutherland Lyall in Building
Design (24
September 1982)
‘The
Egyptian Revival ... is full of attractive matter and is finely
illustrated... Curl’s pertinency has been immense. He points out
a repetitive palmette motif at Malmesbury Abbey of 1170 as a first
harbinger of the Odeon style on our soil. He succeeds in showing
that ancient Egypt has been subject to pretty well uninterrupted
aesthetic borrowing ever since Julius Caesar and Mark Antony dallied
with a Greek queen at Alexandria’ Anthony Quinton in The
Times (7 October 1982)
‘This
beautifully illustrated book will delight the general reader with
an interest in art history and architecture’ Chowkidar
iii/1 (October 1982)
‘The
book is so densely packed with assertions and assumptions that
one is numbed into unquestioning submission. Once in a while the
author raises a point that gives pause for doubt, but invariably
is found to be right... he (has) rehearsed the material, distilled
and reduced it... Like all good works of reference, it gives sources
to which one may immediately return to expand the material ...
(It is) a work of reference ... which in the case of some artists
provides the only material available in English. The
Egyptian Revival is likely to stand alone for a generation
or so, and deserved to be given good looks and comfortable substance’
Brian Sewell in Interiors
(September 1982)
‘The
Egyptian Revival... has an impressively broad scope covering
not only architecture but all the decorative arts from the ancient
world to the present day. It is thus important as the first comprehensive
study of its kind, and it is hard to imagine it being superseded
in the near future... Curl has a field day as he leads us from
Kensal Green to Brookwood
Cemetery
where the Egyptianising tomb-houses in the Parsee section are
the subject of one of the more unexpected plates in the book...
Curl’s relation of Alexander ‘Greek’ Thomson to the Egyptian Revival
is illuminating... The story... in the twentieth century... (is)...
a strikingly satisfying terminus to a fascinating and important
book’ David Watkin in The
Architectural Review (November 1982)
‘As
Curl is at pains to emphasise, the fruits of Bonaparte’s expedition
did not fall upon a world unprepared... The Egyptian Revival ...
traces the influence of Egypt
on European art and culture both forward to modernistic cinemas
and back to the Roman
Empire...
Curl ... painstakingly, indeed remorselessly, lists, and ... provides
many extraordinary and recondite uses of what he calls “Egyptianising”
forms. This (is a) comprehensive pioneering study’ Gavin Stamp
in The Spectator (11
December 1982)
‘Dr.
Curl’s new study is the most comprehensive account of the Egyptian
Revival to appear in print so far ... Unlike most earlier accounts,
he illustrates how Egyptomania gained ground at various points
in the late nineteenth and twentieth centuries. In particular,
he explores the Egyptianising elements in Art Déco and in more
recent design work. It is one of the special features of this
book that it covers theatre design and the decorative arts as
well as art and architecture. Dr. Curl is altogether too modest
when claiming that his book is merely ‘an introductory study of
a recurring theme in the history of taste’. This is a thoroughly
researched and wide-ranging work that draws on an impressive range
of sources ... Architectural and design historians will find a
rich quarry in this well-illustrated work - especially in view
of its substantial and impressive bibliography’ Michael Harrison
in Planning History Bulletin
iv/3 (1982) 23
‘
... the learned author... gives us ... an original work hallmarked
with that perspicuity and lucidity that distinguished his previous
works ... With the help of a comprehensive iconography, Dr. Curl
argues convincingly..., and shows eloquently that Egyptian art
has been seminal for centuries and that its influence has been
almost always beneficial.
His book bids fair to become the standard work on this absorbing
subject’ René Elvin in the Society of Architectural Historians
of Great Britain Newsletter
29 (Winter 1983)
‘The
Egyptian Revival ... (is)... a wide-ranging survey. There
is much intriguing material here... Curl shifts the emphasis of
his study backwards, to the movement’s prolegomena... His final
chapter, ‘The Egyptian Revival in the Twentieth Century’, hints
at an evolution... from eclecticism of taste to eclecticism of
style. In the astounding Egyptian bedroom designed for Lord Battersea...
(c.1903), archaeology and Invention are brilliantly balanced.
And in the Hoover Factory of 1931-32 eclecticism finally triumphs
over undiluted historicism’ J. Mordaunt Crook in The
Times Literary Supplement (18
February 1983)
‘As
demonstrated by the nineteen-page bibliography and the extensive
foot-notes, Mr. Curl has covered a great deal of ground in his
research... The main orientation of his book is towards architecture
and the decorative arts ... sculpture is widely and interestingly
covered’ Clive Wainwright in
The Antique Dealer and Collectors’ Guide (July 1983)
‘Dr.
Curl’s main thesis [is] the influence of Egypt on architectural
... styles, upon which topic he is undoubtedly expert ... A book
concerned with a motif and its occurrence over several centuries
needs to be well illustrated, and here the publishers have done
Dr. Curl proud. The quality of the 203 illustrations overall is
very good and their interest of content exceptionally high...
The text is packed with information ... Certainly there can be
little that has been overlooked in this in-depth survey (it belies
its sub-title of ‘An introductory study’). It is most adequately
backed by extensive footnotes and a detailed bibliography. The
compact design has ensured that what could have easily become
a large and unwieldy tome sits easily in the reader’s hand without
any loss of clarity or presentation. This is a valuable addition
to ‘para-Egyptological’ literature; the Egyptian theme spread
far beyond the Nile
valley and its influence can be seen in many aspects of life about
us today - Dr. Curl rightly draws our attention to its
remaining traces as well as its history. The Egyptian theme is
a recurring one that predates all the others we know so well.
It is good to see such a comprehensive survey of it [is] now available’
Peter A. Clayton in Popular
Archaeology (November 1983)
‘James
Stevens Curl’s latest book... lives up to its subtitle. Drawing
from a multitude of sources, he presents a chronological picture
of the recurring interest in things Egyptian, especially as manifest
in architecture and the decorative arts ... it is ... a useful,
well-documented, and well illustrated account’ Damie Stillman
in Progressive Architecture
(June 1984) 116-7
|